Monday, 17 February 2014

The Role of Media, Marxist perspective. 12.5


Capitalism. A definition:

An economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by a state run by the people.





Marxism. A definition:


The political and economic philosophy of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in which the concept of class struggle plays a central role in understanding society's allegedly inevitable development from bourgeois oppression under capitalism to a socialist and ultimately classless society.




While Karl Marx only knew the press before it was a mass medium, it is still possible to analyse modern media according to his ideas. 

Even though Marxism is widely thought to have failed as a guide to social change.
The media as an industry conforms to a general capitalist type through its factors of production. 

These are likely to be in the monopolistic ownership of the capital owning class and be organised to serve the interest of that class. This is done through the exploitation of workers (ignoring the true value of labour) and consumers (making excess profits).


Media works ideologically by disseminating the ideas and world views of the ruling class, denying access to alternative ideas that might lead to change or to a growing consciousness of the working classes with regards to its interests.


The main contribution of the media is to stimulate and then satisfy false needs. This leads to the assimilation of groups who have no real material interest in common into a 'one dimensional' society.






False consciousness



1.
A Marxist theory that people are unable to see things, especially 
exploitation, oppression, and social relations, as they really are; the 
inability of the human mind to develop a sophisticated awareness of how it is developed and shaped by circumstances.
2.
Any belief or view that prevents a person from being able to understand 
the true nature of a situation.

Marxist theory of media:

  • Mass media is owned by the bourgeois class
  • Media is operated in their interest
  • Media promotes working class false consciousness
  • Media access denied to political opposition.

Task:


Bearing in mind the Marxist theory of media;


Watch the video clip below and analyse with consideration given to the representation of Britain (National Identity).

List the visual codes, Audio codes and geographical markers.
Write 200 words describing what the opening ceremony is saying about being British. What would other nationalities think about this?

Intertextuality, definition.

Relating to or deriving meaning from the interdependent ways in which texts stand in relation to each other.




BBC 1 News





Fox News





The Olympic Opening Ceremony

  • Directed by Danny Boyle who is English.

Visual Codes

  • James Bond (intertextual reference) Daniel Craig is a British actor and James Bond is a prolific film that is well knows for being British.
  • Gold colours signify wealth. Red and Gold are 'royal colours'.
  • Queens guards are used.
  • Black Hackney cab
  • Police officers
  • Throne room
  • Suits
  • Famous Corgi dogs
  • The Queen
  • British flags
  • Flags from other nations sugessts that Britian is accepting of others and multi-cultural nation.
  • Close up of the words 'Happy and Glorious' sums up the British nation.
  • People from all ethnicities and class. Again suggesting is accepting and 'one country'.

Audio Codes

  • Speech - Received Pronunciation by characters and commentator.
  • Classical music used which signifies Britain as being sophisticated and an upper class nation It also reminds the audience of the historical nature of the country and reminds them of royalty.
  • Chimes of the clock which signifies tradition and a reminder of the Big Ben.
  • Dam Busters music is used. The Dam Busters was about world war II and the British attacking the German Dams - This is a reminder to the world that Britain is a superior nation as they 'go into battle' in the helicopter. The music was composed by British composer Eric Coates.
  • Crowds cheering which suggests that the public are proud to be be British and that they are celebrating the culture.

There are various landmarks (geographical markers) that are used:

  • Buckingham Palace
  • Big Ben
  • London Eye
  • River Thames
  • Lion statue in Trafalgar Square
  • Churchill statue
  • London Bridge
  • Houses of Parliament.

Other important points about the representation of Britain (National Identity)

  • Brazilian Children being shown around - They are in awe of the country and everything around them is so much better than their country. Could also suggest that Britian is a multi-cultural society and an acepting nation.

Representations: How the media uses representations 1.5


STEREOTYPE




Stereotype - dictionary definition:
A standardised, often simplified, mental picture or attitude that is held in common by members of a group.
A stereotype is a simplification that we use to make sense of a real person or group which is much more complicated. In reality there are many different kinds of Germans who are all individuals, but it is much easier to fool ourselves into believing that all Germans cheat with beach towels and eat strange sausages. The example that I have just given may seem harmless, but in fact it is arguably racist.
Stereotypes are potentially highly dangerous but stereo- typing itself is impossible to avoid — it is a natural function of the human mind — something that we all do in order to survive mentally in the confusing world around us. The following theory explains how it works.
Representation — How we stereotype:
The fact that we naturally see the world in this kind of shorthand way, with connections between different character traits, allows the media to create simplistic representations which we find believable. Implicit personality theory explains this process.
•       As humans we use our own unique storehouse of knowledge about people when we judge them.
•       Our past experience is more important than the true features of the actual personality that we are judging — traits exist more in the eye of the beholder than in reality.
•       We have each a system of rules that tells us which characteristics go with other char- acteristics.
•       We categorise people into types (e.g. workaholic, feminist etc.) to simplify the task of person perception.
•       Once we have in our minds a set of linked traits which seem to us to go together, they form a pattern of connections that can be called a prototype. In other words the mix of traits that we may consider “typical” of feminists are a prototype of what a feminist is like to us.
•       If we encounter someone in reality or in the media who seems to fit neatly into a pro- totype, we feel reassured. It confirms our stereotyped view — we do not need to think further.
•       Also once a few of the traits seem to fit our prototype, we will immediately bundle onto the person the rest of the traits from the prototype even if we do not know if they fit them in reality.
•       Research has shown that if we find people who do not fit into our prototypes, we will form very strong often impressions of them — it is surprising to us and disconcerting — it forces us to think more deeply.
•       On the other hand, if it is at all possible, we will try to twist the truth to fit in with our prototype, often ignoring traits which do not fit into our neatly imagined pattern of characteristics. This will particularly happen as time passes and we have time to forget things that do not fit in. This can lead to enormous differences between our perceptions of people and the reality.
•       All of this distortion happens naturally in our minds before the media have had their chance to simplify and distort. We do a lot of the business of stereotyping ourselves. It is almost as if we conspire with the media to misunderstand the world.
So stereotyping is something that we all do — a natural part of the way our minds work and not in itself necessarily a bad thing.
Be aware that just as with the process of mediation the stereotypes involve selection, organisation and focusing of the complicated reality.


The four parts of a media stereotype
How can the media build a stereotype? With any group of people, there will obviously be an enormous number of things that can be used in a stereotype, but because stereotyping is a form of simplification, normally the most obvious things are used. These are:
1. Appearance — this can include, physical appearance and clothing as well as the sound of the voice. e.g. “all teachers wear dreadful old clothes”
2. Behaviour — typical things that people in this group might do. “Grannies like to knit”
These first two features of media stereotypes are the same when we make our own stereotypes. They simply involve us thinking of something that may be true of some of the group in question and applying it to all.
The third feature of media stereotyping is peculiar to the media:
3. The stereotype is constructed in ways that fit the particular medium.
This is more difficult to understand but it is crucial for you to look for it. TASK: Compare the stereotype of a serial killer by researching the tabloid coverage of Fred West with the treatment of Hannibal Lecter in the film ‘The Silence of the Lambs’.
If you watch a film such as Silence of the Lambs and then look at the tabloid coverage of Fred West, you are seeing the same stereotype (the typical Serial Killer) being used, but there are obviously big differences which will depend on the specifics of the media used:
The film will use close ups of the killer’s leering face, soundtrack music and reaction shots of terrified victims to create their version of the stereotype.

The newspaper will use emotive headlines, blurred pictures of victims and police mug-shots of the killer along with shocking text and interviews with survivors.
In each case the text will create a stereotype which it’s audience will find familiar, but it will do it in very different ways.

4 There will always be a comparison whether real or imaginary with “normal” behaviour.
If you watch a film such as Silence of the Lambs and then look at the tabloid coverage of Fred West, you are seeing the same stereotype (the typical Serial Killer) being used, but there are obviously big differences which will depend on the specifics of the media used:
The film will use close ups of the killer’s leering face, soundtrack music and reaction shots of terrified victims to create their version of the stereotype.

The features which make up a stereotype are always those which seem somehow different from everyday behaviour. In fact you could almost start any stereotyped description by saying: “this group are different because they...”
Of course the idea of what is normal in any society is an absurdity and therefore in order to make it clear to us that the stereotyped characters are not behaving “normally” there will frequently be “normal” people used to act as a contrast to them.

TASK
Create your own chart of stereotypes based on those that you have encountered in two or more different media (for example, television and newspapers)
Stereotype                      Appearance                 Behaviour                  Media examples

…..Teenagers (age)
…..Old people (age)
……Irish people (nationality)
…..Lesbians (sexuality)
……Mentally disabled (disability)
……New man, (gender)






Representations: The role of selection, construction and anchorage in creating representations 1.5

You will need to be familiar with the following media studies terms:

Selection: The idea that producers and audiences are both selective, eg: editors select the news from that day's events and audiences select what to watch and remember.


Construction: The idea that a media text is not a window on the world but is  a product of individuals in organisations making decisions over the selection of content. In other words;

we see what they want us to see.

Anchorage: a way of ‘tying down meaning’, without anchorage meaning could be polysemic – open to various interpretations, eg a caption anchors meaning to a photo, music anchors mood in a media text.



The Construction and Mediation of Representations
A news photograph for example may appear to be presenting us with a factual image but it has been through a process of construction:
• the photographer has selected his/her position, lens, angle,
exposure and framing before taking the picture
• the picture editor will decide if the image needs to be cropped, enhanced or in any way altered before inclusion into the paper
• an editor will choose which, of the many available photographs of the image, will be the one chosen for inclusion in the newspaper and, importantly at this stage, the images
which do not meet the needs of the text will be rejected
Even then, further mediation takes place:
• Will the photograph be large or small? •     Will the photograph be     on the front page or, less visible, on page 8?
Placement choices like this, along with cropping and framing, act to focus the attention of the reader in a certain way.
• What headline and text will be used to accompany the
         photograph?
•    Will the photograph have a caption?
•    Will it be positioned close to another photograph?

Anchorage is basically used in media to attach meaning to something through either the matching of words to images or the juxtaposition of two images which construct a meaning.
For example in advertising, an image alone is polysemic open to a range of interpretations. To clarify what the image means and so to make the image relevant to the purpose of the advert, text can be added. Thus the image serves as the 'hook' while the text anchors meaning. This can be said also for photographs attached to newspaper articles. The same photograph takes on different connotations with different accompanying texts.

Task 1: 
Open this image in Photoshop and using anchorage, give two captions that would represent the picture in different ways.




Selection
Whatever ends up on the screen or in the paper, much more will have been left out. Any news story has been selected from hundreds of others which the producers have decided were less interesting for you, any picture has been chosen from an enormous number of alternatives.


Omission is knowing about something but just refusing to focus on it or bring light to the facts.

In 2005, the New York Times knew about the Bush Administration using Telecom companies (Verizon, AT&T, etc.) to spy on Americans. The story was held back for over a year as the Times received pressure from Bush White House to kill the story. The Times didn't kill the story completely but they did wait until after the November 2006 elections before they actually reported on Bush Administration breaking the law

Mediation
Every time we encounter a media text, we are not seeing reality, but someone’s version of it. This may seem like an obvious point, but it is something that is easily forgotten when we get caught up in enjoying a text. 
If you see a picture of a celebrity kissing her boyfriend, you may find it unsurprising that the picture has been altered and does not show the reality of the situation, but in fact we should bear this in mind whatever we encounter in the media. 
The media place us at one remove from reality: they take something that is real, a person or an event and they change its form to produce whatever text we end up with. 
This is called mediation. You should be looking for this with any media text.




What the BBC classified as ‘riots’ in London become ‘protests’ in Beitounya


Representations: Disability HW 8.5



DISABILITY ON TV

Disability tends to still be represented in terms of stereotypical characters.  
For example:
·       Physically Disabled / Disfigured – often shown as outsiders, unable to do normal things
·         Mentally disabled – Often shown as strange, odd, childlike, outsiders
·         Able Bodies / Minded – often shown as “normal” and “ideal”.

Characters with disabilities are often portrayed in TV Dramas as being outsiders, strange, unable to do everyday activities, immature, weaker than “able bodied, able minded” characters, less attractive etc.  

Traditionally in films, villains were often given a disability or deformity to make them seem scarier or more evil.  Although our association of disability with “evil” has since declined, society often still links disability to weakness and makes disabled characters objects to pity.

   If you get “disability” as an issue in the exam, you should be thinking about the following things when watching the clip:


·       Can I identify who is able bodied / disabled in the clip?


·        Are people with disabilities shown as having different interests, personalities, attitudes, behaviours from people who don’t have disabilities?  If so, how?

·      Is their disability represented as being important in their life?
·      Are people without disabilities represented stereotypically as being normal / better / more
    powerful?  If so, how?
·      Are people with disabilities represented stereotypically as being abnormal /weak/ pathetic?  
    If so, how?
·      How do other characters in the clip treat the characters with disability?
·      What is the message the clip is trying to portray about sexuality?
   
             Don’t ignore the able bodied characters as they need to be analysed too in                                                                                               comparison!


Examples of disability in TV drama that you can analyse for practise:









A whole collection of film and tv clips that feature disability
          http://www.youtube.com/user/thsmediastudies#p/c/BBC935847FFC4878